Elevate Your Dining Experience at Prime 374

"Dined here with my mother recently and what a delight to find such a gem of a restaurant. I was so surprised to find tucked in the forests of North Jersey exists such an elegant establishment. The food and service were nothing short of what you would expect in NYC fine dining. My mother especially appreciated the ambiance and the sea bass special. My rib eye was very flavorful and came out searing on a hot plate. The staff were very attentive and courteous, the owner even stopped by to introduce himself and ensure everything was to our liking. The overall experience was top notch. I look forward to dining here in the future and exploring the rest of the extensive menu."

"I decided to take my 11 years old nephew for diner. We chose this place because he wanted to eat octopus first time in his life. It was great experience I recommend french onion soup and my nephew really enjoyed the octopus from appetizers menu. Filet steak was cooked how I wanted medium rear. Food was seasoned well and looked good. Server was very nice very welcoming and he did make us feel comfortable. Prices are ok for place like this."

"One of our spots; Love the food and the wait staff. Our meal was delicious as usual. The appetizer was Ari’s seafood salad, the temperature was perfect (room temp) not. Cold the dressing was light and flavorful and the seafood tender and delicious. For dinner we had the Broiled Halibut (reg menu) cooked perfect and my wife had the chicken special (Pollo Al Casa) the sauce was amazing. No room for a solid dessert but we did do an espresso martini (not creamy) in the top 3 of espresso martini’s we have had. We will be back !!! Maggie and Jim"

"Definitely one of West Milford’s best and probably the only fine dining in town. Have been coming here since it was Momento. Under new ownership/management sand great service and food but menu has mich more variety from more expensive (but reasonably priced) steaks to lower (and well) priced chicken and seafood options. We went the steak route tonight. Filet and porterhouse for two. Good apps and desserts too."

"The atmosphere here is beautiful! Me & hubby came here for our anniversary dinner, we started with some clams in white wine (so good!) he had a filet mignon (he can’t stop talking about) I had twin lobster tails that were to die for!! Dessert was even better! We shared a cappuccino, I had the chocolate brownie with ice cream & he had a crème brûlée. This place is truly a GEM! We will definitely be coming back! :)"